Mental
Note to Self : Never (NEVER) READ a book, you accidently clicked on to REVIEW.
About
the Author : Anand
Ranganathan read Chemistry at St. Stephen’s, Delhi ,
and thereafter went to Cambridge
for his BA in Natural Sciences. He stayed on at Cambridge for his PhD and post-doctoral
studies. After returning to India ,
he joined the International Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology at
Delhi , where at
present he is researching tuberculosis and dengue, among other things. The Land
of the Wilted Rose is his debut novel.
My Rant on
this book : Honestly, i was putting of reviewing this book, until I got a
reminder from BLOGADDA about the same. I could review it in THREE WORDS … “WHAT
A MISTAKE”
Are we
still reading for more??? Alright here goes : SO I was a little apprehensive as
to how to review this Book, especially as I was having a tough time reading the
same. So then I force myself to start , and turn the pages(read), and well the
only thing that kept running in my head was , the authors reason of wanting to
come up with this novel. We all are accustomed to Gandhi, and having a “White
Mahatma” did not clearly make any sense to me.
The
initial bit, tries to grab the readers attention , however it tends to loose
its charm. The first page, wherein we are greeted (confusing) by our characters
are just so hard to understand. Anand Ranganathan , in my opinion , did go a
little too far beyond what was required , in etching the situations of people
living in Britain .
However, I
must give the author, credit, for having chosen a subject, that is different
and interesting. However , I personally feel that , he did not do much of a
justice to the unique concept.
We are
welcomed to an era where Britain
is a part of “the great Indian Empire”. It is a play on the colonization of India though here, it is Britain which is ruled by a17-year old king who
dominates almost all the regions of India . This king, referred to as Maharaja , has been
on the throne since the age of 12 and is quite the womanizer. He needs bathing
attendants and has an instant affair with a woman who he later crowns as the
Governess-General of Cyprus .
The concept
has been taken from Mahatma Gandhi and his dedicated struggle towards
independence, however here there is a role reversal of countries, wherein Britain
yearns to free itself from the Indian empire, and “Jack Riley” comes in as the
messiah.
The book has been stretched far more than what was required. The writing style is
detailed, however the usage of too many words at once is annoying.. The
protagonist is the underdog in the book till the end but maybe that’s what the
author intended to do.
The book, seems like a one-sit read because of its size .However,the reality is that you will have to devote time and attention to if you want to read it completely.
It would
have made so much sense to put all the four books into one, than the four series..(Atleast then he did not have to worry about
whether people would read the remaining bit).
Do i
recommend you to read it ??? NO
My Rating
: 2 / 10 (Only because of the uniqueness of the subject)
Ouch :D
ReplyDeleteexactly :P
DeleteIt does sound kind of odd to reverse the countries like that. Maybe that was part of the "comedy".
ReplyDeleteyea, n dats exactly wat i dnt understand :)
DeleteSee? :P
ReplyDeleteya ryt Sri .. Lame excuse .. :P .. but well i think we already got a conclusion to the "book review " bit :)
DeleteOh My God. I build high expectations from Stephanians after reading Amitav Ghosh. This book generally has poor reviews, I just checked. God, must be really sad. :O
ReplyDelete@crystal : Well seems like not all Stephaninas have the same effect :P ..Yes, the book is a little disappointing .
DeleteSo many things to read. Sigh. And you are making the list even longer.
ReplyDeleteLOL, am sure you can skip this one to the very last on your list :P
DeleteUmm..another dissatisfying read...Don't know what to read now...I think the review can be justified. All other reviews of this book too hold the same reviews. Hope these type of books don;t haunt us readers.
ReplyDelete@ Rohit : Dissatisfying is the word... Though the concept is really unique, however no justice has been done to the same
Deleteoops... the author will hide under a pile of blankets and never come out after reading this...
ReplyDelete@Gbtp : Well am not sure of that :D ... :P
Delete